The circumstancial evidence on the ecuadorian organic comprehensive criminal code

Authors

  • Diego Palacios Moreno Universidad Andina Simões Bolivar

Abstract

The circumstancial evidence constitutes one of the different kinds of evidence that allows the connection of a known fact to an unknown fact (subject to evidence) through the inference path. Its treatment in Ecuadorian criminal law has had several guidelines. This essay has as reference the current model of the Ecuadorian Organic Comprehensive Criminal Code in relation to the repealed Code of Criminal Procedure, in order to determine whether or not the current model allows the judgment of the judge to be based on evidence that leads to the declaration of guilt, while the current regulations lack express provisions that regulate this aspect. In addition to this, it is necessary to analyze the requirements established by the repealed procedural
code so that an indication reaches the quality of evidence; and thereby determine if its application is possible in the current model or, failing that, the intervention of recognized sources of law; without prejudice to not knowing the possibility of raising the prohibition that the criminal sentence is based on this quality of evidence.

References

AROCENA, Gustavo; BALCARCE, Fabián; CESANO,José. Prueba en materia penal. Buenos Aires: Editorial Astrea, 2009.

CAFFERATA NORES, José. Manual de derecho procesal. Córdova: Editorial de la Facultad de Derecho de la Universidad Nacional de Córdova, 2003.

ECUADOR. CÓDIGO ORGÁNICO DE LA FUNCÍON JUDICIAL. Registro Oficial Nro. 445, del 20 de Octubre de 2008.

_____. CÓDIGO ORGÁNICO DE LA FUNCÍON JUDICIAL. Registro Oficial Nro. 180 del 10 de Febrero de 2014.

_____. CÓDIGO ORGÁNICO DE LA FUNCÍON JUDICIAL. Registro Oficial Nro. 544 del 09 de Marzo de 2009.

_____. CONSTITUICIÓN DE LA REPÚBLICA DEL ECUADOR, Registro Oficial Nro. 449, del 20 de Octubre de 2008.

_____. Sala de la Corte Constitucional, Sentencia Nro. 025-09-SEP-CC, 29 de Septiembre de 2009. Disponível em: < http://casos.corteconstitucional.gob.ec:8080/busqueda/detalleSentencias.php>. Acesso em: 26 out. 2020.

JAEN, Manuel. Derechos Fundamentales del Proceso Penal. Medellín: Ediciones Jurídicas, 2004.

MITTERMAIER, Carl Joseph Austin. Tratado de la prueba en materia criminal. Madrid: Editorial Reus.1916

PARMA, Carlos; MANGIAFICO, David. La sentencia penal entre la prueba y los indicios. Lima: Editorial Ideas Solución Editorial, 2014.

PARRA, Jairo. Tratado de la Prueba Judicial - Indicios y Presunciones. Bogotá: Editorial ABC, 2005.

PUMPIDO TOURON, Candido. Ley de Enjuiciamiento Criminal, ley y legislación complementaria. Doctrina y Jurisprudencia, Madrid: Editorial Sonepa, 1998.

Published

2021-02-09